Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The minimum wage is there to prevent abuse of workers.

It's pretty obvious why when you look at the near slavery conditions that abused workers doing things like picking tomatos in Florida are subjected to. Shitty businessmen get away with nasty shit when workers lack protection.

The difference between today and 75 years ago is that we now import second class humans again who lack access to basic rights and import goods manufactured by peasants abroad.



My girlfriend, who worked for US Customs, has a story about the sugar industry here in South Florida. Sugar harvesting is done in the winter and the companies, for quality reasons, prefer to have the cane hand harvested. The companies would bring in island workers (legally) to work the three month harvest. The work was hard and by US standards, low paying. But per island standards, those three months brought in enough money for the harvester to not only not work for the remaining nine months, but raise a family.

But enough outcry about the companies "exploiting" the islanders was enough for the companies to say "uncle," and automate the harvest with machines. I'm sure that had an effect on the economies of the islands.



This, a thousand times this.

I can't really explain here why I'm in this situation for a few reasons (particularly anonymity - if my employer finds out I've said any of this I'll be fired and his "friends" will come for a visit), but here's what I can say:

my employer is a thief. Tax fraud, wage theft, copyright violation. Staff are expendable, and routinely fired for not working certain shifts (illegal, because the staff are hired for differing shifts and are not required to work extra). Contract fraud, multiple different types of harassment and abuse of staff, as well as threats against personal safety.

Basically, anything he can get away with to pocket a few dollars, he will do. I'm sure you can imagine that minimum wage is, to him, a target; if it didn't exist, he would pay us much less.

What keeps him in business is powerful friends in government (in a country with "low levels of corruption") who seem to help complaints get lost rather than actioned, and the local gangs who will have a chat with anybody who gets out of line.


> my employer is a thief. Tax fraud, wage theft, copyright violation. Staff are expendable, ... What keeps him in business is powerful friends in government (in a country with "low levels of corruption")

That sound horrible.

Is there anything that can be done to bring such people to justice without exposing dvtv75?


> The minimum wage is there to prevent abuse of workers.

It does part of that, but creates a precarious position for most of the workers. If the minimum wage is higher than the market-clearing wage (as might be evidenced by 100s of applicants for every opening at a fast food restaurant), then the employer knows there is little repercussion for firing (or force-quitting) an employee.

"Plenty more where they came from" and the employee knows that they just passed the 100:1 gauntlet to get this job, so they're a bit more inclined to put up with BS.


Minimum wage is better than nothing, I agree.

But it's worse than most other forms of welfare. We can do better. Much better.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: